• Comics
  • Games
  • TV
  • Movies
  • Music
  • Contests
  • More
    • New Media
    • Books
    • Fan Culture
    • Collectibles
    • Theatre
    • Community Guidelines
  • About

Supernatural 12.04 – “American Nightmare” Recap

November 7, 2016 at 2:00 pm
Kimberly Lynn Workman
Off

With Mary gone and the boys having to deal with the repercussions of her departure, they get right back to the hunt with a case. The attempts to bury themselves in work provided them with some old school connections and some twists thrown in for good measure. And we got a couple of undercover wardrobe changes as well. Therapy, Winchester style.

Note: This recap may contain spoilers!

First off, let’s focus on some petty reveling. I really like when the boys play dress-up, especially when they’re priests. It’s been so long! And not only did they go through one undercover identity, but three, although one was the typical FBI attire. Clerical collars and suits and comfy sweaters, oh my! I miss when the boys would go through the different outfits on a hunt. Somewhere, Dean still has the ranger uniform “just in case.” I like when they explore other identities.

I was hopeful that, with the callbacks to the special children, that maybe Sam’s powers would be returning. Alas, it was not to be. Instead, he met another gifted young girl and tried to help her deal with her plight. While it was touching, I still miss powered-up Sammy. He has shown that he can create much destruction or do overall good deeds if he puts his mind to it. And Ruby even said the could utilize them without the feather of perceived powering-up, so theoretically he could still whip them out if he so desired. But, no, he’s still not able to put them into practice. Oh well. At least he got really jazzed up over what he thought was a daughter’s death and her mother’s apparent disregard for what happened.

The case was a good intertwining of religious control and powers. I really liked the use of the stigmata, and the fact that there was more to this than meets the eye. What at first looked like a weird family who has turned their backs on society and should be condemned for it was actually a group of people who were doing what they thought was right, some out of love and some out of twisted blame. But the deaths that happened as a result of Magda’s isolation were not done out of malice, but instead out of a need to seek out a connection. Magda has been so brainwashed by her mother that she thinks she is really evil for the acts she’s caused, both the deaths and her mother’s accident. I liked that the reasons behind the family’s disconnection from the world, the changes that they went through and the accident and everything, were all well-connected and made sense in the larger scope.

And I liked that Dean is still working through Mary’s departure and trying to reach out to her, despite feeling betrayed. Abandonment and Dean Winchester are well-acquainted. Kudos to Sammy for attempting to help Dean work through it. Pushing down the hurt and trying to avoid the issue, like Dean tends to do, is not healthy and will not allow him to work through the real issues at play. It took him a while, but Dean finally gets that time away from them doesn’t mean Mary doesn’t love them. She will return when she’s ready, but until then she’ll keep in touch from afar. Her message to Dean showed that. They can be a family again, but right now they just need to let Mary find her place in the world.

At least they know about Vince now, though they both seemed to know him by reputation before the whole Lucifer possession thing. I loved that Sam was a hidden fan, much to Dean’s displeasure. I’m not sure if Lucifer is out of that vessel now or if he will use his previously-seen power to restore Vince to his former self. We can use Rick Springfield for a couple more eps, right? But the Winchesters don’t yet know about Mr. Ketch, and that’s going to be an interesting discovery indeed. They think Lucifer’s going to be their big bad to deal with, but Mr. Ketch is going around cleaning up their messes by killing those that they saved. Oh, boys, your lives are never simple.

Rating: 4 / 5 Stars

Screencaps by SupernaturalWiki

recaps, Supernatural

You might also like:

  • Supernatural 15.02 – “Raising Hell” RecapSupernatural 15.02 – “Raising Hell” Recap
  • Supernatural 15.01 – “Back and to the Future” RecapSupernatural 15.01 – “Back and to the Future” Recap
  • Supernatural 14.20 – “Moriah” RecapSupernatural 14.20 – “Moriah” Recap
  • Supernatural 14.19 – “Jack in the Box” RecapSupernatural 14.19 – “Jack in the Box” Recap
  • Supernatural 14.18 – “Absence” RecapSupernatural 14.18 – “Absence” Recap
About the Author
In her youth, Kimberly could be found in the library, devouring books that covered everything from WWII History to Dr. McCoy's latest adventures aboard the Enterprise, with some X-Men thrown in for good measure. Saturdays were often reserved for PBS re-runs of Doctor Who and Red Dwarf. More recently, she's been riding along with the Winchester brothers, and she hopes the Impala doesn't run out of gas for a long time.
  • Contest: Win Three Clint Eastwood Classics on 4K and Digital!
  • Contest: Win Batman Ninja Vs. Yakuza League on 4K and Digital!
  • Contest: Win Companion on 4K and Digital!
  • Contest: Win Red One on 4K and Digital!
  • Contest: Win Amadeus on 4K and Digital!

Follow Us!

© 2008-2022 Fandomania | Privacy Policy