• Comics
  • Games
  • TV
  • Movies
  • Music
  • Contests
  • More
    • New Media
    • Books
    • Fan Culture
    • Collectibles
    • Theatre
    • Community Guidelines
  • About

Comic Review: WALL-E #7

June 15, 2010 at 11:00 am
Ryan Whiting
Off

WALL-E Cover-Issue 7

Issue: WALL-E #7
Release Date: June 16, 2010
Writer: Bryce Carlson
Artist: Morgan Luthi
Colors: Digikore Studios
Letterer: Jose Macasocol, Jr.
Covers A & B: Morgan Luthi
Publisher: BOOM! Kids

Well, that was a quick read. I had originally scheduled to have WALL-E read one night, written and proofread the review the next, and then posted sometime later on in the week. However, I was able to get all three done in one sitting. That’s not necessarily a good thing.

The usual suspect... consumerism!

The usual suspect... consumerism!

When WALL-E was released in 2008, it collected rave reviews, with critics praising its style, simplicity and, perhaps most importantly, the cute message behind it all. Beneath WALL-E’s metal exterior and bright eyes, the film managed to teach us a lesson of sustainability and to appreciate not only our Earth, but, indirectly, ourselves as well. Beyond the vision of a trash-torn world and an overweight human race were reasons, and, as it turned out, we were the cause of our home’s destruction.
Pixar doesn’t want to let that happen.

And so I loved WALL-E and delighted in its touching and almost speechless tale, bringing a romance perhaps as beautiful as Titanic. Pixar managed so much emotion with so little dialog, and the intermittent whirs of its leading members were vocal enough to make a point.
And that’s why, when I saw WALL-E on the list of comics available for review, I jumped at the opportunity. After all, how could an experience so gorgeous on the big-screen fail in a format so suited for graphics and sweeping stories?

Apparently, it could, as WALL-E’s comic book escapades certainly are underwhelming, and hindered by its almost too kid-friendly focus. Indeed, it’s classically clichéd and classically watered-down, with practically no gripping content.

Issue 7 picks up exactly where number 6 concluded, with Andy and WALL-E running for a spaceship in the distance. As it blasts off into the sky, Andy becomes more and more desperate to catch it and hopefully find a way to reunite with his family. Because, you know, you can totally reach a shuttle mid-way through take-off from thousands of feet away. Logic? I see none, but that’s beside the point.

Apparently, onomatopoeias are the new communication trend.

Apparently, onomatopoeias are the new communication trend.

But, as they get closer, Andy’s hopes at a lift home are crushed, and the apparent spaceship turns out to be little more than an oversized advertisement for the all-dominant Buy-N-Large. An ultimately anti-climactic twist, it’s a disappointing turn that sets no real urgency for the rest of the issue. So, instead, what comes next is merely a mesh of disconnected occurrences. We’re taken through a slew of underwhelming plot devices that do nothing for the story; instead, they’re just there to fill an issue. Andy gets startled and drops an important computer chip; WALL-E takes the already distressed astronaut on a bumpy ride through a sand storm; the two enjoy a moment’s rest in WALL-E’s home. And, of course, only one of those events serves importance to the central plot, and such a part is, while formulaic in execution, possibly the best-handled aspect of the issue.

That, unfortunately, isn’t saying much, as the rest of the comic is already terribly mediocre and drab. Even the art is rather dull, with very little appreciation for imagination or detail. Simplistic and filled with too many annoying scratches, some of the caricatures come off almost ugly. The repetition of mammoth-sized onomatopoeias, too, gets old after a while, with some pages littered with them. Granted, the art direction’s not a complete disaster, for the cover illustration of WALL-E’s upward peering eyes is nicely juxtaposed with an embedded image of a rocket taking flight.

But, in and of itself, there’s not much to be excited about here, and almost everything about WALL-E’s adventure is rather pedestrian and played out. There’s little emotion in the dialog, and creativity seems to be devoid. In the end, the story wraps up too cleanly and in the manner we all knew it would.

WALL-E, in its film form, was a testament to Pixar’s artistic genius, balancing striking animation with pitch-perfect story. But, when translated to ink and paper, that leveled scale seems to collapse.

Rating: 1.5 / 5 Stars

BOOM! Studios, comics-, Reviews, wall-e

You might also like:

  • Comic Review: WALL-E #6Comic Review: WALL-E #6
  • Planet of the Apes: Cataclysm #3 Comic ReviewPlanet of the Apes: Cataclysm #3 Comic Review
  • Planet of the Apes: Cataclysm #2 Comic ReviewPlanet of the Apes: Cataclysm #2 Comic Review
  • Planet of the Apes: Cataclysm #1 Comic ReviewPlanet of the Apes: Cataclysm #1 Comic Review
  • Exile on the Planet of the Apes #4 Comic ReviewExile on the Planet of the Apes #4 Comic Review
About the Author
Ryan Whiting lives on an island you've probably never been to and probably care little about. Bermuda, a 21-square mile land mass 700 miles off the coast of New York, is an unlikely place to find such a geeky writer. But he exists and types away, ranting about bad story-telling in video games or raving about last night's episode of 24. That is, if it was any good, of course. But contrary to what his website may say, Ryan's geekdom is not overly eclectic, and he keeps to his fandoms. He's not really into comic books or anime (save for a few exceptions) and, when it comes to that vampire craze, he'd have a hard time discerning even Jacob from Edward. So, he stays away from such areas and sticks to what he likes. Ryan's in love with serialized dramas, sci-fi shows, and video games, specifically RPGs and FPS's. He'd also like to consider himself a film critic, but only for the movies he doesn't walk out on. He won't do it again. He promises. Ryan's also a bit of a techy, and, whenever possible, tries to stay up-to-date on whatever's current or popular in the gadget-world. Yes, he has to have that latest thing, whatever it is. Outside of confining himself to either his favorite shows on DVD or the gadget blogs, Ryan has a vested interest in photography, and totes his SLR with him to most places. He even has a photoblog over at Flickr that he updates whenever he can (http://www.flickr.com/ryanwbermuda). Living on a such a small island can be tough at times, but Ryan, along with his family and friends, works out just fine. For more of Ryan, check out his website: www.ryanjwhiting.com or Twitter page: www.twitter.com/rwhiting.
  • Contest: Win The Alto Knights on Blu-ray and Digital!
  • Contest: Win Mickey 17 on 4K and Digital!
  • Contest: Win Three Clint Eastwood Classics on 4K and Digital!
  • Contest: Win Batman Ninja Vs. Yakuza League on 4K and Digital!
  • Contest: Win Companion on 4K and Digital!

Follow Us!

© 2008-2022 Fandomania | Privacy Policy